
AC Hotel New York Times Square
Best for easy access to Times Square, Broadway theatres, and a lively rooftop evening scene.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
AC Hotel New York Times Square is a modern, midscale-luxury Marriott property in the Theatre District with a rooftop bar and straightforward business amenities; this guide is for travelers who want easy access to Times Square and Midtown. The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel is a classic Upper East Side five-star with an old‑New‑York reputation and a full-service spa; read on if you prefer landmark luxury near Central Park and museums.
Updated · about 3.5 km apart

Best for easy access to Times Square, Broadway theatres, and a lively rooftop evening scene.

Best for a traditional, upscale Manhattan stay within walking distance of Central Park and the Met.
AC Hotel New York Times Square wins when you want a contemporary Midtown base close to Times Square, Penn Station and a 21st-floor rooftop bar for evening drinks. It's practical for theatre-goers, business travelers and those who value a 24/7 fitness center and newer rooms.
The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel wins when you want classic, Upper East Side luxury: a smaller, quieter address near Central Park, a full-service spa, Bemelman's Bar and the status of a longtime landmark property with Rosewood service standards.
Bottom line: pick AC Hotel for a modern, active Midtown stay with a rooftop scene and convenient transit links; pick The Carlyle if you want old‑school luxury, a central Upper East Side address and a more intimate, full‑service hotel experience.
| Category | AC Hotel New York Times Square | The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Contemporary, business-forward Midtown hotel with rooftop nightlife | Classic, refined Upper East Side luxury with an old‑New‑York feel |
| Location | 260 West 40th St — Theatre District, steps from Times Square and Port Authority | 35 E 76th St — Upper East Side, about a 10-minute walk to Central Park and the Met |
| Size | 290 rooms across 21 floors | 188 guestrooms |
| Opened / age | Opened April 5, 2018 (newer property) | Not published |
| Pools | No pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Boqueria (Spanish tapas) and Castell Rooftop Lounge (21+, rooftop bar) | 2 restaurants including Bemelman's Bar and room service; 1 bar/lounge |
| Spa / wellness | No on-site spa; 24/7 fitness center is complimentary | Full-service spa available |
| Known for | Value-oriented Midtown location, rooftop views and Barcelona-style dining | Timeless luxury, proximity to Central Park and museum access |
| Good for | Theatre District sightseeing, transit connections, rooftop evenings | Luxury stays, quieter neighbourhood, museum and Central Park visits |
AC Hotel sits on West 40th Street in Manhattan’s Theatre District, a short walk to Times Square, Penn Station and many Broadway theatres.
Pick AC Hotel if you want to be in the thick of Midtown activity and transit.
The Carlyle is on East 76th Street near Madison Avenue, within a short walk of Central Park and several major museums.
Choose The Carlyle for quieter, museum- and park-focused neighbourhood access.
AC Hotel has 290 contemporary rooms across 21 floors with options for city views and some rooms offering balconies or terraces.
AC Hotel delivers newer, modern rooms tailored for Midtown stays and business travel.
The Carlyle offers 188 guestrooms and a range of suites—names include Superior King, Deluxe Room, Premier Suite and multiple Rosewood-branded suites.
The Carlyle provides traditional luxury rooms and many suite options for a more intimate stay.
AC Hotel has two on-site venues: Boqueria (Spanish tapas) and Castell Rooftop Lounge (21+, panoramic views).
AC Hotel is a good choice if you want lively, modern dining and a rooftop bar scene in Midtown.
The Carlyle lists two restaurants and one bar/lounge, with room service and a notable bar experience.
The Carlyle suits guests seeking formal dining options and classic hotel bar service near the Upper East Side.
AC Hotel’s signature guest amenity is its 21st-floor Castell Rooftop Lounge plus a 24/7 fitness center.
AC Hotel emphasizes a rooftop social scene and round-the-clock fitness rather than spa services.
The Carlyle’s standout amenity is a full-service spa alongside classic hotel facilities.
The Carlyle is geared toward travelers who prioritize in-house spa and full-service luxury conveniences.
AC Hotel combines a 24/7 fitness facility with a rooftop bar that anchors its evening scene.
AC Hotel fits guests who want to work out any time and finish the day with rooftop cocktails.
The Carlyle offers quieter, upscale evening options and a full-service spa for daytime wellness.
The Carlyle is better for relaxed, high-touch evenings and in-house spa treatments.

AC Hotel — steps from Times Square, Broadway theatres and major transit hubs.

The Carlyle — traditional five-star service, close to Central Park and the Met.

AC Hotel — Castell Rooftop Lounge offers panoramic views and an active evening scene.

The Carlyle — a full-service spa and Rosewood-level amenities for a pampering stay.
The Carlyle is closer — roughly a 10-minute walk to Central Park; AC Hotel requires a subway ride or longer walk from Midtown.
AC Hotel New York Times Square is the better choice for Broadway and Theatre District access, within a few blocks of many venues.
AC Hotel does not have a pool. The Carlyle's supplier listing does not publish pool information.
The Carlyle offers a full-service spa; AC Hotel New York Times Square does not have a spa.
Neither property is adults-only; both accept guests of all ages, though some venues (Castell Rooftop Lounge) have age restrictions for entry.
Explore how AC Hotel New York Times Square stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·