
AC Hotel New York Times Square
Best for travelers who want a centrally located, contemporary Midtown hotel with a lively rooftop and value-focused amenities.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
AC Hotel New York Times Square is a modern, midscale Marriott property in Midtown's Theatre District with a rooftop bar and a focus on practical, design-forward rooms. The St. Regis New York is a historic, full-service Fifth Avenue luxury hotel known for butler service and classic grand-hotel rooms — read this if you need a practical Midtown base vs. a traditional luxury Fifth Avenue stay.
Updated · about 1.2 km apart

Best for travelers who want a centrally located, contemporary Midtown hotel with a lively rooftop and value-focused amenities.

Best for travelers seeking a traditional Fifth Avenue luxury experience with Butler Service and a long-standing high-end hotel pedigree.
When AC Hotel New York Times Square wins: choose AC Hotel if you want a newer property in the Theatre District, easier access to Times Square/Broadway, a 21st-floor rooftop bar (Castell), straightforward rooms, and generally lower nightly rates than a full luxury hotel.
When The St. Regis New York wins: pick The St. Regis for classic Fifth Avenue luxury, extensive meeting and event spaces, suites with Butler Service included in many room types, and a more formal, high-touch service profile.
Bottom line: AC Hotel is a practical, modern Midtown pick centered on nightlife and theatre access; The St. Regis is for travelers who prefer historic Fifth Avenue luxury and butler-style service. Your choice depends on whether you prioritize rooftop social life and location near Times Square or formal luxury and a Fifth Avenue address.
| Category | AC Hotel New York Times Square | The St. Regis New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Contemporary, design-forward Midtown hotel focused on practicality and rooftop socializing | Historic grand luxury hotel with formal service and Butler Service on many room types |
| Location | 260 West 40th Street — Theatre District, ~5-minute walk to Times Square | Two East 55th St — Fifth Avenue, near Rockefeller Center and 5th Avenue shopping |
| Size | 290 guestrooms across 21 floors | 238 guestrooms |
| Age / opening | Opened April 5, 2018 (newer property) | Historic property (long-established Fifth Avenue hotel) |
| Pools | No pool or hot tub | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Boqueria (Spanish tapas) + Castell Rooftop Lounge (21+, rooftop bar) | 2 restaurants, 1 bar/lounge; room service available (limited hours) |
| Spa / wellness | No on-site spa; 24/7 fitness center (complimentary) | Not published |
| Known for | Rooftop bar with city views and close access to Broadway/Times Square | Butler Service, Fifth Avenue address, historic luxury |
| Business & events | 4 event rooms totaling 3,765 sq ft, rooftop indoor/outdoor venues | Conference space 3,944 sq ft with 13 meeting rooms |
| Accessibility & policies | Accessible rooms and public areas; minimum check-in age 21; pets not allowed | Accessible features listed; check-in minimum age not published here |
AC Hotel sits on West 40th Street in the Theatre District a short walk from Times Square and major transit hubs.
Pick AC Hotel for immediate access to Broadway, Times Square, and transit connections.
The St. Regis anchors a Fifth Avenue address near Rockefeller Center, luxury shopping and museums.
Choose The St. Regis for a classic Fifth Avenue location and proximity to Midtown's upscale attractions.
AC Hotel's 290 rooms are modern, compact and designed for city stays, with some rooms offering balconies or terraces.
AC Hotel focuses on contemporary, efficient rooms for sightseers and business travelers.
The St. Regis offers a range of classic guest rooms and suites, many marketed with Butler Service included.
The St. Regis emphasizes spacious, traditionally styled rooms and suites with Butler Service on many options.
AC Hotel centers dining around Boqueria (Spanish tapas) and Castell Rooftop Lounge (21+ rooftop bar).
AC Hotel is a good pick if you want lively tapas and a social rooftop scene without leaving the hotel.
The St. Regis lists two restaurants and a bar/lounge, with room service available during limited hours.
The St. Regis suits guests who expect traditional hotel dining and a formal food-and-beverage experience.
AC Hotel does not have a pool; its rooftop lounge is the hotel's signature public amenity.
AC Hotel's rooftop replaces a pool as the main social amenity.
The St. Regis is known for Butler Service and formal luxury; details on a pool are not published in the supplied listing.
Butler Service and traditional luxury are The St. Regis' defining amenities; pool information is not published.
AC Hotel offers a complimentary 24/7 fitness center and a rooftop bar for evening socializing.
AC Hotel balances fitness access with rooftop nightlife rather than spa services.
The St. Regis lists concierge, 24-hour front desk and on-site hair salon and shopping; spa details are not published in the supplied listing.
Expect formal service and in-house conveniences at The St. Regis; specifics on a spa are not published in the supplied listing.

AC Hotel — walk to Times Square and Broadway in minutes, and it sits across from the Port Authority Bus Terminal.

The St. Regis — choose this for a Fifth Avenue address, historic hotel atmosphere and Butler Service included in many room types.

AC Hotel — Castell Rooftop Lounge is a year-round rooftop bar with city views and late-night hours on weekends.

The St. Regis — extensive meeting rooms, ballroom space and concierge services suit formal events and luxury stays.
AC Hotel New York Times Square is about a 5-minute walk to Times Square; The St. Regis is farther (still walkable but roughly 0.7–1.2 km away).
AC Hotel does not have a pool or on-site spa and focuses on a 24/7 fitness center instead. For The St. Regis, spa and pool details are not published in the supplied listing.
The St. Regis is the clearer pick for formal luxury experiences and Butler Service; AC Hotel is a modern, more casual Midtown option.
Yes — AC Hotel has 4 event rooms and rooftop venues totaling 3,765 sq ft; The St. Regis lists roughly 3,944 sq ft of conference space and 13 meeting rooms.
Explore how AC Hotel New York Times Square stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·