
AC Hotel New York Times Square
Best for travelers who want direct access to Times Square, Broadway theatres and a 21+ rooftop evening scene without luxury price tiers.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
AC Hotel New York Times Square is a modern, midscale Marriott property in Midtown Manhattan with Spanish tapas and a rooftop bar—good for travelers who want fast access to Times Square, Broadway and transit. The New York EDITION is a 5-star, design-focused luxury hotel by Madison Square Park for travelers comparing stylish lifestyle hotels and signature restaurants in Manhattan.
Updated · about 1.2 km apart

Best for travelers who want direct access to Times Square, Broadway theatres and a 21+ rooftop evening scene without luxury price tiers.

Best for travelers who want a design-forward, full-service luxury stay near Madison Square Park with on-site spa services and a signature restaurant.
When AC Hotel New York Times Square wins: choose AC if your priority is being in the Theatre District, quick access to Times Square and a lively rooftop bar plus an affordable, modern Marriott experience with straightforward, business-friendly amenities.
When The New York EDITION wins: pick the EDITION if you want a 5-star, design-oriented hotel near Madison Square Park, prefer a hotel with an on-site spa and signature dining (The Clocktower), and value a more upscale, lifestyle-focused stay.
Bottom line: AC is the practical Midtown option for sightseeing, transit and rooftop evenings; The New York EDITION is the upscale, design-focused choice for travelers seeking luxury services and a Madison Square Park address.
| Category | AC Hotel New York Times Square | The New York EDITION |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Contemporary, midscale urban Marriott with Spanish-influenced dining and a social rooftop bar. | 5-star, design-led luxury lifestyle hotel focused on style and service. |
| Location | 260 West 40th Street — Theatre District, steps from Times Square and Port Authority. | 5 Madison Avenue — near Madison Square Park and the Flatiron/Gramercy area. |
| Size (rooms) | 290 guest rooms across 21 floors. | 271 rooms (supplier listing). |
| Adults policy | All-ages hotel; minimum check-in age 21. | |
| Pools | No pool or hot tub on-site. | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Boqueria (Spanish tapas) + Castell Rooftop Lounge (21+ rooftop bar). | The Clocktower restaurant + 2 bars/lounges; 24-hour room service available. |
| Spa & wellness | No on-site spa; complimentary 24/7 fitness center with Peloton and weights. | Spa treatment room(s) and on-site spa services; fitness facilities listed. |
| Meeting & event space | 4 event rooms totaling 3,765 sq ft, rooftop event space for up to 125 guests. | Conference space of 2,100 sq ft and 5 meeting rooms. |
| Accessibility & sustainability | Accessible rooms and public areas; LED lighting and water-efficient showers. | |
| Typical guest use | Sightseeing, Broadway/theatre trips, business travelers needing transit access. | Guests seeking a luxury, design-forward stay and nearby Madison Square/Flatiron dining. |
AC Hotel sits on West 40th Street across from the Port Authority and a short walk to Times Square and Broadway.
AC is best if you want to be in the heart of Midtown theatre and transit connections.
The New York EDITION is positioned by Madison Square Park, close to Flatiron, 5th Avenue and neighborhood restaurants.
The EDITION suits travelers who prefer the Madison Square/Flatiron neighborhood to Midtown’s theatre hub.
AC Hotel offers contemporary, compact rooms focused on comfort and functionality.
AC’s rooms are modern and straightforward—designed for sightseers and business guests who value location.
The New York EDITION provides 5-star rooms with design-forward finishes and luxury bedding.
The EDITION offers a higher-end room product with more luxury touches and suite options.
AC centers food and drink around Boqueria’s Barcelona-style tapas and the 21+ Castell rooftop lounge.
Choose AC for convenient tapas, a lively rooftop and easier Midtown dining access.
The New York EDITION features a signature restaurant (The Clocktower), two bars and 24-hour room service.
The EDITION emphasizes full-service dining and bar experiences as part of its luxury offering.
AC’s signature amenity is its rooftop Castell bar and its central Midtown views—there is no pool.
AC’s rooftop bar is the property’s main social and scenic feature in lieu of a pool or spa.
The New York EDITION lists spa treatment room(s) and spa services on-site as a key service.
If an on-site spa and full-service luxury amenities matter, the EDITION is the stronger option.
AC provides a complimentary, accessible 24/7 fitness center and an evening rooftop scene for guests 21+.
AC mixes around-the-clock fitness and a sociable rooftop for nights out near Broadway.
The EDITION pairs spa services with more formal bars and lounges for an upscale nightlife experience.
The EDITION leans toward polished evenings and in‑house wellness services rather than casual rooftop nightlife.

AC Hotel New York Times Square — steps from Times Square, theatre venues and major transit hubs.

The New York EDITION — a 5-star, design-focused hotel near Madison Square Park with on-site spa services.

AC Hotel New York Times Square — Castell Rooftop Lounge provides panoramic views and a happy hour crowd.

The New York EDITION — The Clocktower and multiple bars plus 24-hour room service for a full luxury experience.
AC Hotel New York Times Square is much closer to Times Square and the Broadway theatre district; The New York EDITION is near Madison Square Park, farther south.
AC Hotel New York Times Square does not have a pool. The New York EDITION’s supplier listing does not publish pool details.
The New York EDITION lists spa treatment room(s) and on-site spa services; AC Hotel New York Times Square does not have an on-site spa.
Both hotels offer Wi‑Fi; AC provides complimentary public-area Wi‑Fi and in-room policies vary by rate/Bonvoy status, while The New York EDITION lists complimentary wired and wireless internet access.
Explore how AC Hotel New York Times Square stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·