
AC Hotel New York Times Square
Best for visitors who want straightforward Midtown access, a late-night rooftop scene (21+), and a more affordable central base near Times Square.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
AC Hotel New York Times Square is a modern, midscale Marriott property in the Theatre District with a 21st-floor rooftop bar and easy access to Times Square. The Peninsula New York is a five-star Fifth Avenue luxury hotel with a full-service spa, indoor pool, and classic Midtown address; this guide helps travelers choose between a practical Midtown base and a high-end Fifth Avenue stay.
Updated · about 1.2 km apart

Best for visitors who want straightforward Midtown access, a late-night rooftop scene (21+), and a more affordable central base near Times Square.

Best for travelers who prioritize traditional Fifth Avenue luxury, spa and pool facilities, and a full-service hotel experience.
When AC Hotel New York Times Square wins: pick AC Hotel if you want to stay in the Theatre District, be within a short walk of Times Square and Broadway theatres, and enjoy a convenient, modern hotel with an all-season rooftop bar and complimentary 24/7 fitness center.
When The Peninsula New York wins: choose The Peninsula if you want classic Fifth Avenue luxury, in-room comforts like premium bedding, access to a full-service spa and indoor pool, multiple bars/lounges, and concierge or limo/town-car services.
Bottom line: AC Hotel is a practical, contemporary Midtown pick for sightseers and nightlife-adjacent stays; The Peninsula is a pricier, full-service luxury option for travelers seeking Fifth Avenue refinement, spa time, and more on-site amenities.
| Category | AC Hotel New York Times Square | The Peninsula New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Modern, practical, theatre-district focused | Formal, fifth-avenue luxury |
| Location | 260 West 40th Street — Theatre District, steps from Times Square | 700 Fifth Avenue at 55th Street — Midtown, on Fifth Avenue near MoMA |
| Size (guest rooms) | 290 guestrooms across 21 floors | 219 guestrooms |
| Ages / audience | All-ages property; minimum check-in age 21 | All-ages property; minimum check-in age not published |
| Pool | No pool or hot tub on-site | Indoor pool (1) |
| Spa / wellness | No on-site spa; complimentary 24-hour fitness center | Full-service spa with treatments, 24-hour health club |
| Restaurants & bars | Boqueria (Spanish tapas) + Castell Rooftop Lounge (21+, Mediterranean-style small plates) | Clement Restaurant (American) + 3 bars/lounges and 24-hour room service |
| Event & meeting space | 4 event rooms totaling 3,765 sq ft; rooftop event options | 5 meeting rooms and banquet hall |
| Known for | Proximity to Times Square, rooftop bar and modern rooms | Beaux-Arts luxury on Fifth Avenue, spa and high-end service |
| Wi‑Fi | In-room Wi‑Fi available; complimentary for Marriott Bonvoy members who book direct; public-area Wi‑Fi free | Free WiFi (wired and wireless) in public areas and rooms |
AC Hotel sits on West 40th Street in the Theatre District, a short walk to Times Square, Broadway theatres and Midtown transit hubs.
Choose AC Hotel for the most convenient access to Times Square, theatres, and Midtown transit.
The Peninsula is on Fifth Avenue at 55th Street, steps from the Museum of Modern Art and high-end shopping on Fifth Avenue.
Choose The Peninsula if you want a Fifth Avenue base near museums, shopping, and Midtown attractions.
AC Hotel offers 290 modern guest rooms across 21 floors with some rooms featuring floor-to-ceiling windows and private balconies/terraces.
AC Hotel rooms are contemporary and practical, geared to sightseers and business travelers who value location.
The Peninsula has 219 guestrooms in a Beaux-Arts building with premium bedding and in-room entertainment.
The Peninsula focuses on classic luxury rooms and suites with higher-end in-room amenities and services.
AC Hotel pairs a Barcelona-style tapas restaurant with a 21+ rooftop lounge that serves Mediterranean-style small plates and cocktails.
AC Hotel is the pick for tapas-focused dining and an accessible rooftop cocktail scene.
The Peninsula offers a full-service restaurant and multiple bars/lounges, plus 24-hour room service for in-room dining.
The Peninsula provides a wider range of on-site dining and lounge options for a traditional luxury hotel experience.
AC Hotel does not have a pool or hot tub and directs guests to its 24/7 fitness center for on-site exercise.
If an on-site pool or spa is essential, AC Hotel is not the right choice.
The Peninsula includes a number of recreational amenities including an indoor pool, sauna and a full-service spa.
The Peninsula is the clear choice for travelers who want an on-site pool and a full spa program.
AC Hotel’s wellness focus centers on its 24/7 fitness center; nightlife is anchored by the 21+ Castell Rooftop Lounge.
Pick AC Hotel if you want a 24/7 gym plus a lively rooftop bar for evenings.
The Peninsula blends a traditional luxury evening atmosphere with spa and pool-based wellness options.
The Peninsula works well for travelers seeking a quieter, full-service evening program and in-house wellness treatments.

AC Hotel New York Times Square — walking distance to Times Square, Broadway theatres, and major transit hubs.

The Peninsula New York — full-service spa, indoor pool, sauna, and 24-hour health club.

AC Hotel New York Times Square — Castell Rooftop Lounge (21+) with panoramic views and happy hour.

The Peninsula New York — classic Beaux-Arts address on Fifth Avenue with multiple bars/lounges and high-touch service.
AC Hotel New York Times Square is much closer to Times Square (about a 5-minute walk); The Peninsula is farther uptown near Fifth Avenue and MoMA.
The Peninsula New York has an indoor pool and a full-service spa. AC Hotel New York Times Square does not have a pool or a spa.
Yes — Castell Rooftop Lounge is described as an all-season rooftop bar, though outdoor seating and hours may vary by weather and private events.
The Peninsula lists free wired and wireless internet. AC Hotel offers free Wi‑Fi in public areas; in-room Wi‑Fi is complimentary for Marriott Bonvoy members who book direct, otherwise it may be fee-based.
Explore how AC Hotel New York Times Square stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·