
AC Hotel New York Times Square
Best for skyline cocktails, a 21+ rooftop vibe and being steps from Times Square and Broadway.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
AC Hotel New York Times Square is a modern, midtown Theatre District hotel with a lively rooftop bar — good for travelers who want nightlife and easy Broadway access. The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel is a refined Upper East Side luxury address near Central Park and the Met — read this if you prefer quieter, classic luxury and a full-service spa.
Updated · about 2.1 miles (3.4 km) apart

Best for skyline cocktails, a 21+ rooftop vibe and being steps from Times Square and Broadway.

Best for a quieter, refined Upper East Side stay with easy walking access to Central Park and museum row.
When AC Hotel New York Times Square wins: pick AC Hotel if you want to be in the heart of Midtown near Broadway, enjoy a lively rooftop bar (Castell Rooftop Lounge), and prefer a contemporary, well-located base for theatre, transit and nightlife.
When The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel wins: choose The Surrey if you want classic, small‑hotel luxury on the Upper East Side, proximity to Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art, and a hotel with a full-service spa and Italian dining (Casa Tua).
Bottom line: AC is a modern, energetic Midtown option for city-first sightseeing and rooftop evenings; The Surrey is a quieter, higher-end Upper East Side option for museumgoers and guests who prioritize refined rooms and spa services.
| Category | AC Hotel New York Times Square | The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Contemporary, energetic Midtown hotel with rooftop nightlife | Quiet, refined Upper East Side luxury hotel |
| Location | 260 West 40th Street — Theatre District, steps from Times Square and Port Authority | 20 East 76th Street — Upper East Side, ~5‑minute walk to Central Park and close to the Met |
| Size (rooms) | 290 guest rooms across 21 floors | 100 guestrooms |
| Ages / access | All ages welcome; check-in min age 21 | All ages welcome (not adults-only); check-in min age not published |
| Pools / beach | No pool or hot tub on-site | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Boqueria (Spanish tapas) and Castell Rooftop Lounge (21+, rooftop) | Casa Tua (Italian restaurant), 24-hour room service, bar/lounge |
| Spa & wellness | No on-site spa; 24-hour fitness center (complimentary) | Full-service spa with massages and facials; fitness classes on site |
| Known for | Rooftop bar with panoramic views and easy Broadway access | Proximity to Central Park and the Met, Frette sheets and refined rooms |
| Parking | No on-site garage; validated off-site self-parking ~0.8 miles away (no in/out privileges) | Covered valet parking available (surcharge) |
| Wi‑Fi & business | In-room Wi‑Fi available (complimentary for Bonvoy members who book direct); business center and meeting rooms | Free WiFi; concierge and express check-out; limo/town car service available |
AC Hotel is in the Theatre District, blocks from Times Square, Broadway theatres and transit hubs.
Stay here for Midtown convenience and being in the middle of Broadway/Times Square activity.
The Surrey sits on the Upper East Side, a short walk to Central Park and major museums.
Choose The Surrey for a refined Upper East Side base near Central Park and museum row.
AC Hotel offers modern, compact rooms across a large Midtown tower.
Expect contemporary, efficiently designed Midtown rooms with some city-view options.
The Surrey provides fewer, more traditionally luxurious guestrooms and suites.
If you want a smaller, more luxurious room inventory with traditional bedding and suite options, The Surrey fits that need.
AC Hotel's food and drink scene centers on a lobby Spanish restaurant and a 21st-floor rooftop lounge.
AC is the choice for rooftop cocktails and casual Spanish tapas near Times Square.
The Surrey emphasizes Italian dining and full room service for a quieter dining experience.
The Surrey suits guests seeking classic Italian dining and full-service hotel amenities.
AC Hotel does not have a pool; its signature amenity is the Castell rooftop lounge and 24/7 fitness center.
AC delivers skyline views and a 24/7 gym rather than pool or spa facilities.
The Surrey highlights a full-service spa and traditional luxury hotel services.
The Surrey’s signature draw is its full-service spa and personalized service.
AC combines a 24-hour fitness center with an active rooftop bar that runs late on weekends.
Pick AC for late-night rooftop energy plus round-the-clock gym access.
The Surrey leans toward low-key evenings, post-museum dinners and in‑house spa time.
The Surrey is better for relaxed evenings, spa visits and museum-focused days.

AC Hotel New York Times Square — rooftop bar and Theatre District location put you close to shows and late-night options.

The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel — a short walk to Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art.

The Surrey — full-service spa and in-room treatment reservations available.

AC Hotel — larger modern property with direct access to Midtown attractions and public transit.
AC Hotel New York Times Square — it sits in the Theatre District and is a short walk to many Broadway theatres.
The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel has a full-service spa; AC Hotel New York Times Square does not have an on-site spa.
No — neither property is adults-only. Standard check-in policies (AC minimum check-in age 21) still apply.
AC Hotel New York Times Square does not have a pool. The Surrey's supplier listing does not publish pool details.
The Surrey is on a quieter Upper East Side street and tends toward relaxed evenings; AC is in busy Midtown near nightlife and theatres.
Explore how AC Hotel New York Times Square stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·